Rule Change Proposal- Draft Pick Time Limit
-
As you know we currently have a 12-hour time limit on all draft choices. This was put into place when the league started in 2009. There was a slight change to 8 hours in round 3-10 but recently was voted back to 12 hours for every pick.
The 12 hour limit was set mainly to compensate for overnight and working hours. Today we can set queues and timers and, at the very least, send proxy picks to an administrator.
I propose a 6 hour limit on all picks and tutorials on how to set queues at the draft site. We already urge members to send proxies if they aren’t able to draft themselves. -
B BHows pinned this topic on
-
Just posting the role regarding these proposals for the benefit of our new GMs.
If a referendum receives 8 co-sponsors, the referendum would be presented for vote to the entire league.
- The referendum must receive a simple majority of all current GMs to pass.
- Referendums to the entire league would have a period of fourteen (14) days to be approved. If a majority approval is not granted within the 14 day period, the referendum is denied.
- At any time during the referendum process, the rules committee could elect to consider and implement a referendum. In this case, a vote to deny the rule proposal by the executive committee would not prevent the referendum from moving forward.
- A particular topic may be brought to a vote once per season whether proposed by the rules committee or by referendum.
- a. An exception to this rule can be made, if a GM wishes to propose a referendum on a denied rules change.
-
L ldsjayhawk moved this topic from Rulebook on
-
L ldsjayhawk unpinned this topic on
-
-
The reason we made this change was the difficult we were having staying on top of it. I have no objection to an 8 hour time limit, but 6 hours seems a little short for me.
-
-
I am going to say no you shouldn’t change rules mid draft - I would say it is ok to have a 8 hours draft clock from 2027 but not in this one
-
-
I am supportive of 6 or 8 hours, starting in the 3rd round. I recognize that it’s not ideal to change mid draft but I’m ok with it. If we need to have an overnight pause in order for the change to pass I’m ok with it but Fantrax does have great queuing functionality
-
-
-
@zedgemon I understand, I like to pick too and we've always urged GMs to send someone their pick. It's less than desirable but you get what you want.
We have had a situation the last 24 hours where there has been 1 pick made. No, it's not that we have time constraints, we don't. It comes down to being able to enjoy your time here. I hardly think I'm the only person here who has found this very frustrating. Maybe I'm wrong -
-
-
I would be OK with an 8 hour time clock starting in the third round with an overnight pause.
-
-
I also would be in favor of an 8-hour time clock at the beginning of the draft to the end with an overnight pause.
-
I agree with a 6 or 8 hour clock and an overnight pause.
-
An 8 hour clock with an overnight pause could extend a pick out to as much as 16 hours. I have never been in a draft with that, so I'm open to hearing how that would be better than just a straight 12 hour clock? I do get that the day would go faster.
-
-
I personally don't mind a shorter clock, just not sure it should be changed mid-draft. If one is instituted though, it should have the over night pause.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login